2024
Composite Materials from Soy Meal and Soy Hulls both modified with Soy-Based Polymers
Contributor/Checkoff:
Category:
Industrial
Keywords:
CoatingsSoy hullsSoy meal
Parent Project:
This is the first year of this project.
Lead Principal Investigator:
Andriy Voronov, North Dakota State University
Co-Principal Investigators:
Project Code:
NDSC 2024 New Use 9
Contributing Organization (Checkoff):
Institution Funded:
Brief Project Summary:
Three end products are obtained while crushing soybeans: oil, meal and hulls. Among three products, soy hulls have the least value. This project’s main goal is to investigate feasibility of using soybean meal and soybean hulls simultaneously in polymer composites and thermoplastics. Researchers intend to convert soybean meal and hulls into materials processable using a standard film extrusion technology. They will develop a procedure for obtaining modified composites with properties and performance comparable to petroleum-based counterparts of thermoplastics and composite films.
Key Beneficiaries:
#engineers, #farmers, #scientists
Unique Keywords:
#industrial use, #new uses, #plastics, #polymer composites based on soybean meal and hulls, #soy-based plastisizing and hydrophobizing polymers, #soybean hulls, #thermoplastics based on soybean meal and hulls
Information And Results
Project Summary

Three end products, oil, meal and hulls, are obtained while crushing soybeans. First, the beans are cracked to remove the hulls. After oil is extracted, soy meal remains. Due to physico-chemical properties and biodegradability, inexpensive soy meal has a potential to be applied for manufacturing of value-added plastics and polymer composites. Among three products, soy hulls have the least value. The 2021 crop year totaled a record-high 4.5 billion bushels in soybean production. Based on hulls content in soybeans (3 to 5 lbs. per bushel), the 2021 crush generates 180 million lbs. of hulls that may find value-added applications.

This proposal’s main goal is to investigate feasibility of using soybean meal (SM) and soybean hulls (SH) simultaneously in polymer composites and thermoplastics. SM and SH mainly contain two constituents - soy protein and carbohydrates (polysaccharides and various mono-, di- and oligosaccharides). Both components possess decent physico-chemical properties, but are highly sensitive to humidity and lacking mechanical performance, so needed to be modified.
Project main goal is to convert in one step (using NDSU-developed soy-based polymer technology, U.S. Patent, 10,315,985 B2 and U.S. Patent, 10,584,094 B2) SM and SH into materials processable using a standard film extrusion technology. For this purpose, we will need to develop a procedure for obtaining modified SM and SH composites with properties and performance comparable to petroleum-based counterparts to be applied in composites and thermoplastics.

Identifying industrial partners to help with evaluating performance of the developed soy-based polymer composites and thermoplastics is targeted

Project Objectives

There are three closely interconnected objectives to achieve the main project goal to develop sustainable technology for the biobased thermoplastics and polymer composites from soy meal (SM) and soy hulls (SH).
Objective 1. Monomers Synthesize soybean oil-based (SBM) and high oleic soybean oil-based (HO-SBM) monomers with different level of unsaturation.
Objective 2. Polymers Develop procedure of SM and SH modification with SBM/HO-SBM- based polymers.
Objective 3. Films and Composites Formulation and characterization of thermoplastics and composite films from modified SM and SH.

Project Deliverables

1. Preparation of polymeric materials from SM and SH both modified with soy-based plasticizing and hydrophobizing polymers to enable composites and thermoplastics formation.

2. Characterization and testing of the prepared soy-based materials to determine their feasibility to be applied as thermoplastics and polymeric composites.

Longer term goal is to develop thermoplastics and polymer composites based on modified SM and SH and test them at industrial partner facilities (will be identified during this project) to evaluate perspectives of this new product commercialization.

Progress Of Work

Update:
Research Overview and Objectives
The main goal of this project is to investigate the feasibility of using soybean meal (SM) and soybean hulls (SH) in polymer composites/thermoplastics simultaneously. SM and SH contain two main constituents - soy proteins and carbohydrates (cellulose, hemicellulose). Both are sensitive to humidity and lack mechanical performance on their own. Additionally, soy proteins, hemicellulose, and cellulose are practically non-processable materials in film extrusion technology. Hemicellulose and cellulose are inherently rigid and, consequently, non-film-forming biopolymers. Abundant hydrogen bonding makes them incompatible with hydrophobic polymers and plasticizers, which complicates their homogeneous incorporation as reinforcing additives. On the other hand, soy proteins are flexible macromolecules that readily undergo conformational changes but are too hydrophilic to combine with other polymers. Hence, SM and SH constituents must be modified to convert them into processable thermoplastics while retaining their advantages, such as being able to be obtained from renewable feedstock and natural biodegradability.
The basic concept of this project is to engineer thermoplastics from SM and SH via covalent grafting (attachment) of soft and flexible hydrophobic soybean oil-based monomer (SBM) and/or high-oleic soybean oil-based monomer (HO-SBM) side chains. We hypothesize that modification of SM and SH constituents with soy-based (plasticizing/hydrophobizing) polymer side chains converts them into processable materials using a standard extrusion process. For this purpose, we need to develop a procedure for soy protein/hemicellulose/cellulose modification with soy-based polymers.
This work has three main goals. The first one is the synthesis of soybean oil-based (SBM) and high-oleic soybean oil-based (HO-SBM) monomers for modification of SM and SH. Second, is the development of a procedure for SM and SH modification with polymer side chains from SBM/HO-SBM. The third objective is the formulation/characterization of thermoplastics and composites from SM and SH modified with SBM/HO-SBM.

Completed Work: Deliverables and/or Milestones
This project has two milestones, modification of a complex mixture of hemicellulose, cellulose, and proteins from a renewable feedstock (SM and SH) and its application as composites and thermoplastics.
The outcome of this project will be the first attempt to modify natural resources without prior purification and separation of constituents. The thermo-mechanical properties are compared with the formulations of pure modified constituents to evaluate the effect of residual components, such as lipids, lignin, and pectin, which are in the minority in SM and SH. Testing of the prepared soy-based polymeric materials will determine their feasibility to be applied as thermoplastics or as additives into the polymer matrix to obtain composites.

Progress of Work and Results to Date
To date, Objective 1 has been completed. Scaled-up laboratory batches of SBM and HO-SBM for modification of SM and SH can be synthesized. The chemical structure and fatty acid composition of monomers are characterized by FTIR and 1H NMR spectroscopies. Additionally, the reactivity of these monomers in free radical polymerization has been studied. Thermo-mechanical characterization shows that both SBM and HO-SBM homopolymers have low glass transition temperatures, which can be used for the plasticization of rigid counterparts such as hemicellulose and cellulose.
To date, Objective 2 is in progress. Both hemicellulose and cellulose contain hydroxy groups in the polymer backbone, and their modification includes two steps – substitution of hydroxy groups with the functional groups and grafting from these functional groups via free-radical polymerization of the monomer of interest. The principal difference is in different molecular weights or heterogeneity of aforementioned polysaccharides, therefore different reaction conditions are required. Hemicellulose modification with soy-based polymers (from SBM and HO-SBM) has been carried out. To modify hemicellulose, 2 strategies were implemented. The first includes the reaction of maleic anhydride (MA) with hemicellulose hydroxy groups and further reaction of MA vinyl double bond in free-radical polymerization with SBM/HO-SBM. In this case, the mixture of grafted hemicellulose and homopolymers of SBM/HO-SBM are obtained. The latter can be beneficial to the final material properties forming a matrix for grafted hemicellulose. The advantage of this method is its simple experimental procedure and lower sensitivity to the experimental conditions.
In the second approach, hydroxy groups are reacted with a-bromoisobutyryl bromide to yield macroinitiator, which is further used in controlled free-radical polymerization. This method allows the precise control of the length of polymer side chains during the grafting process as well as increased purity of final material (homopolymer of SBM/HO-SBM is not formed during the reaction).
To date, the first method, utilizing maleic anhydride to obtain grafted hemicellulose, is completed. Maleinization of hemicellulose was conducted in bulk at a 4:1 molar ratio of MA to monomer unit of hemicellulose (anhydroxylose). Then, maleinized hemicellulose was grafted in the presence of HOSBM and free radical initiator yielding grafted hemicellulose and homopolymer of HOSBM. The final material was purified and characterized using 1H NMR spectroscopy and thermal analysis (DSC).
In the second method, hemicellulose was reacted with a-bromoisobutyryl bromide and obtained material characterized using 1H NMR spectroscopy. In the following step, the synthesized macroinitiator will be reacted with the SBM/HO-SBM to obtain polymer side chains of chosen length using controlled free-radical polymerization. Based on the reaction mechanism, it is assumed that the final materials will not contain the homopolymer of SBM/HO-SBM.

Work to be Completed
Currently, the cellulose modification process is being carried out. To conduct successful modification of such a high molecular weight biopolymer as cellulose, it is crucial to achieve proper dispersion during the modification reaction. Therefore, we conduct experiments to define the solvent, which could maximize the solvation of cellulose hydroxy groups and thus increase the efficiency of hydroxy group substitution. The experimental conditions will suit both strategies – maleinization of cellulose and synthesis of macroinitiator. The obtained modified cellulose will be further used in conventional free-radical polymerization and controlled free-radical polymerization to yield grafted material.
Another constituent of SH and SM – soy protein is a complex mixture of proteins (for instance, glycinin and ß-conglycinin); hence, we will conduct the identification of functional groups, which can undergo modification.

We will be continuing to develop a procedure for SBM- and HO-SBM-based polymer's covalent attachment to SM/SH constituents - cellulose, hemicellulose, soy protein – to investigate the feasibility of modified SM and SH in making thermoplastics and composites. Further, we aim to study the physical and chemical properties of the modified SM and SH constituents as well as thermoplastic films and biocomposites thereof. Upon finishing the modification of separate constituents of SM and SH, formulations that have a similar composition to the initial feedstock will be prepared, and their thermo-mechanical properties will be evaluated. The final objective will be to proceed with direct modification of SM and SH, its characterization, and comparison of the properties to previously prepared formulations.

Other relevant information: potential barriers to achieving objectives, risk mitigation strategies, or breakthroughs
The major potential risk is an inability to approach the target level of physical characteristics of the synthesized polymeric materials, which may be limited due to the quality and composition of feedstock materials, specifically SH and SM. The major direction of mitigating the potential problems is to search for and use different sources of cellulose, hemicellulose, and soy protein.

Summary
The synthesis of SBM/HO-SBM (Objective 1) has been performed, and both monomers are characterized and available for Objective 2. The team conducted a series of grafting experiments to verify the feasibility and the concept of grafting SBM- and HO-SBM-polymers to hemicellulose (part of Objective 2). In the second part of this project, modification of cellulose and soy protein will be conducted. After that, thermo-mechanical characterization of formulations with modified hemicellulose, cellulose, and soy proteins will be performed (Objective 3).

View uploaded report Word file

Final Project Results

Benefit To Soybean Farmers

This proposal aims to provide the feasibility of using soy meal and soy hulls obtained during soybean crushing process in the state of North Dakota for high value and high profit thermoplastic and composite polymeric materials with properties comparable to their petroleum-based counterparts. Using inexpensive soy meal and abundant soy hulls as a feedstock in value-added plastic and composite products may bring more revenue to ND soybean farmers.

Obtained results are expected to benefit North Dakota soybean farmers because the findings will diversify soy-based products with increased demand for soy meal and soy hulls. New soy-based polymeric products on the market will help the state of North Dakota economy to involve investors and other soy processing industries.

The United Soybean Research Retention policy will display final reports with the project once completed but working files will be purged after three years. And financial information after seven years. All pertinent information is in the final report or if you want more information, please contact the project lead at your state soybean organization or principal investigator listed on the project.